Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label EIQ

EIQ is flawed so stop using it

And this is where everyone laughs at me. "No one uses EIQ you dummy," is what you're probably thinking. Well yeah, the too good to be true way to quantify pesticide toxicity is just that, too good to be true. It really is too bad because having an easy-to-use way to assign pesticides a toxicity was very convenient and promised to be a very powerful decision making tool. For those of you who are concerned about quantifying pesticide toxicity it is helpful to learn why the EIQ doesn't work and what, if anything, we can use to quantify our pesticide use going forward. Basically, the reason that that EIQ is flawed is that it relies way too heavily on application rate. The higher the application rate the higher the EIQ would be. The impact on rate was so high that a weed scientist, Andrew Kniss , assigned random values to the EIQ toxicity parameters  73,000,000 times and found that the random values "provided the same recommendation as the EIQ about 88% of the time....

Why Does Phosphite Matter?

Last year I wrote a Debbie Downer article about phosphite and how it isn't as environmentally friendly as you might think. Just because it is marketed as a fertilizer doesn't mean that it doesn't have an environmental impact. We all know the impacts fertilizer can have on the environment. Disease is no big deal these days (knock on wood) I use the total cost of pest control and the EIQ to quantify my pesticide use . Even though the EIQ is flawed, it's the most user friendly and useful way to measure the environmental impact of a product applied to a golf course. With my data collection I have found that by incorporating phosphite into my disease management strategy I have been able to keep costs and the EIQ relatively unchanged. That means that the phosphite makes up for its cost and EIQ in reductions in cost and EIQ of traditional pesticides. So in the end there really is no difference, on paper anyway. Since I incorporated phosphite into my disease management program...

Pesticide Use Summary 2015

2015 was my second full year tracking my pesticide use costs and EIQ in a detailed way. Overall I think my year was as good as can be expected as far as disease management goes. For the most part I was able to keep things under control and I came in under budget for costs and EIQ. As always I still only use pesticides on my putting greens which make up less than 1% of the total area of the golf course property (1 acre of 0.4ha). In 2015 I spent less on pesticide for the golf course than any other year in recent memory. I think the reason why I was able to spend less this year was that we had a very dry summer and I was able to go from mid May to late August without a broadcast pesticide spray on my greens. I have had further success this fall with my last broadcast pesticide application occurring on Oct 23rd 2015. That's over 80 days ago! This year I was made aware that the EIQ is a flawed method to determine the actual impact of pesticides on the environment. Here is an article t...

Is Phosphite an Environmentally Friendly Alternative to Traditional Pesticides?

This week I had a discussion on Twitter about a statement made that phosphite use will help reduce the environmental impact of pesticides on the golf course. The guru of phosphite in turf, John Dempsey, stated this in his thesis abstract. 250 word abstract with 2 words to spare :) pic.twitter.com/0eNkMIBZOu — John Dempsey (@J_J_Dempsey) April 22, 2015 I have done quite a bit of work looking at the environmental impact of different products that we apply on the golf course using Cornell University's EIQ calculator . The EIQ calculation is, in my opinion, the most comprehensive and meaningful way to measure the impact of certain products used for pest control on the golf course. I wrote about this in a blog post " Sustainable Pesticide Use: Tracking Pesticide Cost and Environmental Impact ." I also shared my observations after tracking my EIQ for an entire season in a post " EIQ Tracking, My First Year ." Tracking the EIQ has been an enlightening experience for me...

EIQ Tracking, My First Year.

Putting down an application of phosphite and primo in mid December 2014 before it gets dark! It has now been almost an entire year since I started tracking my pesticide use in a meaningful way. Last year I discussed different ways we can measure our pesticide use on the golf course and discussed how the cost and EIQ (Environmental Impact Quotient) were the only real metrics that mattered. You can read all about this in my post: Sustainable Pesticide Use: Tracking Pesticide Cost and Environmental Impact By mid year 2014 I was seeing a lot of success with my tracking and goal setting. I claimed that I was ahead of my goals for pesticide cost and just about right on track with my EIQ goals. Now that the year has come to an end I can look back and see how I did. Did I achieve my goals? The answer is yes and no. Here are the numbers: Sustainability Metric YTD Total Cost Goal Percent of Goal Used Cost Fusarium $4,401.56 $5,000.00 88.03% Cost Dollar Spot $312.17 $400.00 78.04% Total Cost $4,7...

Is the best solution always the best?

Often when we search for solutions to our pest problems we are presented with the best most effective solution. Obviously this is what we would expect, especially when coming from a consultant or expert. No one wants to recommend something that might not really work that good right? Typically the best solution is the one that provides the best control. What if we have other criteria? Doesn't true IPM practices demand alternative actions? Case in point this summer I had a particularly bad outbreak of Cyanobacteria on my putting greens. I did some quick research and the main recommendation I found was to spray cholorthalonil. Great. A simple and relatively cheap solution. The only problem is that I have set some rather stringent EIQ goals for pesticide use. One light application of chlorothalonil would use up half of my yearly budgeted EIQ. I needed another option. Chlorothalonil would only be used in a worst case scenario. I would continue to research options and closely monitor th...

Pesticide Tracking First Half of 2014

It has now been 6 months since I started tracking the cost and EIQ of pest control products at the Pender Harbour Golf Club. So far I am doing great with keeping with my set goals. Sustainability Metric YTD Total Cost Goal Percent of Goal Used YTD Progress Days Percent of Total Next App Max Cost Fusarium $1,964.89 $5,000.00 39.30% 46.58% 7.28% 27 84.37% $363.87 Cost Dollar Spot $0.00 $400.00 0.00% 46.58% 46.58% 170 0.00% $186.30 Total Cost $1,964.89 $5,400.00 36.39% 46.58% 10.19% 37 78.12% $550.17 Fusarium EIQ 348.23 800.00 43.53% 46.58% 3.05% 11 93.46% 24.38 Dollar Spot EIQ 0.00 1.00 0.00% 46.58% 46.58% 170 0.00% 0.47 Total EIQ 348.23 801.00 43.47% 46.58% 3.10% 11 93.34% 24.84 As you can see I am almost 37 days ahead of my cost goals and 11 days ahead of my EIQ goals. I am not bragging either. The act of monitoring, setting goals, and making informed decisions has made it extremely easy to keep on track with my goals that I set out in my original Pesticide Tracking Post.  I can ta...

Disease Update March 2014

You probably aren't wondering what that crazy greenkeeper is up to in Pender Harbour but I'm going to tell you anyway! Overall disease pressure has been interesting. On areas that receive no treatment (fairways, tees) the disease was pretty bad. I have talked with a few other superintendents and most are all seeing the same thing: Crazy bad fusarium on fairways, especially on approaches. This is even apparent on approaches that had fungicide applications made in the fall. I have made no fungicide applications of any kind to my approaches. As the sun rises in the sky I have observed the grass start to out-compete the fusarium and recovery has begun! Bad fusarium. Possibly made worse by mower spread. Already recovering nicely. My fusarium management plan has evolved over the years and here is what I am trying right now. I am not using Civitas. I think I have seen damage due to phytotoxicity especially when it is frosty. I also  don't like the green colour . Any areas that wer...